Season 2

1. The Search for Mr. Christmas

2025-10-27 · 42m

Host Jonathan Bennett and judge Melissa Peterman kick off the hunt for Hallmark's next leading man as ten new hunks reinvent Santa, and then brave a ski-slope meet-cute with Janel Parrish.

2. Reindeer Games

2025-11-03 · 42m

The hunks team up to launch gifts into Santa's sleigh, then soar sky-high as reindeer in an Entertainment Weekly photo shoot, where the winning team's advantage shakes up the competition.

3. Riding Into Romance

2025-11-10 · 42m

The hunks get personal while building gingerbread houses, sharing what Christmas means to them; Alison Sweeney joins as they saddle up for a cowboy scene, where animal co-stars lead to some unexpected performances.

4. A Very Merry Talent Show

2025-11-17 · 42m

The hunks slide through a messy Festive Face Off before cleaning up for the Mr. Talent show; with Hallmark Superfans as guest judges, the guys are faced with tough questions; it all leads to an elimination with a shocking twist.

5. Christmas on Main Street

2025-11-24 · 42m

The hunks roll into giant plastic balls, crashing through Christmas trees in a wild Festive Face Off; with Hunter King as guest judge, teams perform a neighborhood holiday party scene that leads to a dramatic elimination.

6. The Holi-date

2025-12-01 · 42m

A very quiet morning leads to an Christmas date with unexpected surprises.

7. Merry Christmas Mom

2025-12-08

The final four pen holiday cards to their moms before being surprised with live reunions. Icon Sharon Lawrence guides them to channel raw emotion into a heartfelt holiday scene, supported by the people who love them best.

8. Crowning Mr. Christmas

2025-12-15 · 42m

Erin Krakow joins Jonathan Bennett and Melissa Peterman to step back in time and into the story, acting alongside the finalists in a holiday scene with a Christmas kiss; one man is crowned Mr. Christmas.

9. Finding Mr. Christmas: Reunion Special

2025-12-20 · 42m

Host Jonathan Bennett gathers the guys for an inside look; finding out what they've been up to; hearing from the winner!