Season 1

1. Fake ‘em Out

2025-09-16

Laura Wallen of Columbia, Maryland and a former teacher of the year, is eagerly anticipating the start of a new school year and her upcoming engagement. That’s what makes it so shocking when she doesn’t show up for the first day of school. Unsure whether they have a missing person case, or a murder case, detectives zero in on three potential suspects. But as the case stalls and time runs out, detectives launch a bold and unconventional plan to uncover what really happened to Laura – and bring the truth to light.

2. Untangle the Lies

2025-09-16

When Joleen Cummings, a hairstylist and mother, goes missing, detectives discover strange behavior and hidden secrets that turn a missing person case into a more sinister investigation.

3. Step Back

2025-09-23

The murder of Connie Dabate in what appears to be a home invasion leaves a quiet Connecticut community stunned. A surprising piece of evidence surfaces, cracking the case wide open.

4. Don't Buy the Alibi

2025-09-23

A beloved teacher, Jocelyn Peters, is shot and killed in her bed. Her boyfriend's alibi checks out, but a new lead emerges from an unexpected discovery at the crime scene.

5. Hit the Road

2025-09-30

A beloved teacher, Jocelyn Peters, is shot and killed in her bed. Her boyfriend's alibi checks out, but a new lead emerges from an unexpected discovery at the crime scene.

6. Never Give Up

2025-09-30

A man named Mike Williams goes missing while on a duck hunt in Florida, and authorities initially suspect an alligator attack. The case is closed until a surprising turn in the investigation years later unravels a chilling tale of greed and betrayal