Season 1

1. Anna Garcia

2024-02-14 · 30m

Catherine sits down with actress and comedian Anna Garcia to, among other things, hatch the world's worst karaoke song.

2. Ellory Smith

2024-02-28 · 31m

Join Catherine as she attempts to woo comedian and writer Ellory Smith on this week's episode of Pretty Gay. Her opinions and inherent charm are dazzling.

3. Sarah Schauer

2024-03-13 · 31m

Enjoy the wonderful comedy stylings of Sarah Schauer on this episode of Pretty Gay. Join Catherine for lots of laughs and one very informative moment about how to pick up women at a bar.

4. Pallavi Gunalan

2024-03-27 · 31m

Catherine dates comedian Pallavi Gunalan. Discussion points: coming out of the closet, the appropriate amount of ransom, and who keeps the dildo in the divorce. Featuring a mom and even a dad!

5. Hannah Pilkes

2024-04-10 · 23m

Catherine welcomes the silly sexy stylings of Hannah Pilkes. Delight at the wonders of uncanny impressions, reading each other's minds and singing what can only be called a very original song.

6. Yazmin Monet Watkins

2024-04-24 · 30m

Yazmin Monet Watkins dazzles us this week at Pretty Gay. Catherine McCafferty may have every single red flag Yazmin name but that won't stop our host from trying to win Yazmin over with jokes, astrology, and far too many thumbs' ups.